Problems with turner thesis

The Turner Thesis: A Problem in Historiography - jstor

When Frederick Jackson Turner quietly announced his frontier thesis 60 years ago, it caused little more than a ripple in historical circles. Thirty years later, not only was it widely accepted as the primary explanation of American growth, but AmericanThe Frontier Thesis or Turner Thesis, is the argument advanced by historian Frederick Jackson Turner in 1893 that American democracy was formed by the American frontier. He stressed the process—the moving frontier line—and the impact it had on pioneersRay Allen Billington's Westward Expansion (1949) was for decades the standard textbook in the field; his skillful revision of the Turner thesis kept the idea of what he ... Echoing the interest of historians in other fields in issues of race, gender, ethe historians' "pros and cons" of the Turner frontier thesis. He con- cludes the controversy over Turner with ... 2 A number of excellent analyses and evaluations of the Turner thesis have been made. Among the most significant are the ... Frontier proDavidson's and Lytle's summary of Turner's thesis and perceptions of Jackson is a classic illustration of a major problem that has plagued the thesis since the 1930s-the frequent tendency of scholars, especially critics, to oversimplify or distort it. ~HYPER/TURNER/. *. A paper read at the meeting of the American Historical Association in Chicago, July 12, 1893. It first appeared in the Proceedings of the. State Historical Society of Wisconsin, December 14, 1893, with the following note : "The founda29 Nov 2017 ... Andrew Achenbaum problems with the frontier thesis explains the essay argumentative an in refutation many problems involved in doing research that spans disciplinary boundaries. Learners identify problems we see in this bookyou can provThe wilderness disappears, the “West” proper passes on to a new frontier, and, in the former area, a new society has emerged from this contact with the backwoods . Gradually this society loses its primitive conditions, and assimilates itself to the typeWith these words, Frederick Jackson Turner laid the foundation for modern historical study of the American West and presented a "frontier thesis" that continues to influence historical thinking even today. Turner was born in Portage, Wisconsin, in 1861Lacy Ford comments: “As small-farm America disappeared, Turner, an affectionate son of the middle border, saw his worst nightmare realized: a cramped, crowded, “Europeanized” America that was losing its distinctiveness. (( Lacy Ford, Frontier Democracy-